An update: This was, I must confess, the worst post in the history of Gawker. I said several things I don't really believe, and I said other things I do believe in the worst manner possible. Usually Gawker has an unofficial "don't let them see you bleed" attitude, but my post was such a failure that loyal readers of the site — many of them — wrote in to say they'd never read it again. I do in fact think killing puppies is a horrible and reprehensible thing. I admittedly hold a certain callousness toward the story not shared by the vast majority of readers. I also failed to properly communicate my point: That this one atrocity was being publicized far beyond its relevant meaning, and that given the pillorying of the suspected killer, it seemed wrong that killers of civilians had not been all the more harassed and destroyed. (That, and not "for the pageviews," is why I wrote the piece.) I will now return to my usual role as Gawker's worst writer. The original post still follows.
Radar Online has a "harsh video warning" for this clip of an American soldier in Iraq throwing a puppy off a cliff. Sure, the idea's sick, but the video is as worksafe as a Bugs Bunny cartoon. By the time the puppy lands, the little thing is too far out of sight to see in the grainy YouTube clip. But as Radar reports, a blog has already accused U.S. Marine David Matari as the perp of this heinous, terrible, loathsome act. Where could he have learned such violence and carelessness toward life? Oh yeah. Watch the clip (oh come on, grow a pair) and argue whether killing a puppy is still sad if it happens in the middle of a war.
See? A cruel thing to do, but not a human rights violation. At least when my vile middle-school classmate tortured frogs, he made them suffer. The puppy surely died on impact. It has the trappings of sadness, but how does that make it much worse than a euthanization?
Media blogger Rex Sorgatz explains viewer angst:
Logically, we know this soldier has possibly killed people in Iraq, so it feels misplaced to vent about a puppy in a war zone; emotionally, we find hurting a helpless puppy beyond reproach. If the video weren't shot in Iraq (if it were, say, some tweens torturing a dog in a backyard -- you'll find plenty of this on YouTube), the tension wouldn't be there, and it wouldn't be today's viral hit. The contradiction -- people vs. puppies; war vs. peace-keeping -- will probably catapult this thing to network nightly news.
